Should You Reimburse an EV Driver Less Than a Gas Driver?
An operator put this to me recently, and not gently: "That seems shady to pay an employee with an EV less than someone that uses gas." He was reacting to a sentence of mine that compared fuel cost per mile and stopped there, which is a fair thing to object to.
The intuition behind the objection is that electricity is cheap, so an EV driver gets a smaller check. The intuition behind the original sentence is the same one, just pointed the other way. Both are wrong, because fuel is one line out of six and it is not the one that decides the answer.
This piece runs the whole comparison line by line, shows which way it actually lands, and names the one case where paying an EV driver less is correct rather than shady.
Run all six lines, not the one on the pump
Here is the same store, the same 20,000 miles a year, and two vehicles: a new compact sedan at about $24,000 and a new EV at about $42,000. Every figure is modeled by our cost engine at one California ZIP.
Your gas price, your power price, your two vehicles
Opens on roughly national energy prices, so it will not match the California figures in the table below. The two energy lines move most by market. Set yours and watch whether the answer flips. Nothing leaves your browser.
Modeled, not a quote. Insurance, maintenance, tyre and registration figures are held at the modeled values for these two classes and do not move with your inputs; the energy, depreciation and sales tax lines do. A real rate is priced at your ZIP from carrier filings.
The line-by-line answer, and it is not the one people expect
| Cost line | New gas compact | New EV | EV difference |
|---|---|---|---|
| Energy, fuel or power | 18.66c | 7.74c | 10.92c cheaper |
| Maintenance | 7.86c | 4.37c | 3.49c cheaper |
| Depreciation | 13.66c | 23.63c | 9.97c dearer |
| Insurance | 15.26c | 19.07c | 3.81c dearer |
| Tyres | 1.55c | 2.87c | 1.32c dearer |
| Tax and registration | 2.01c | 3.29c | 1.28c dearer |
| Total | 59.00c | 60.97c | 1.97c dearer |
The EV is cheaper on two lines and dearer on four. The two savings come to 14.41 cents a mile. The four extra costs come to 16.38 cents. So on this pairing the EV driver's vehicle costs about two cents a mile more to operate, and a rate that pays them less is the one that underpays.
Notice which line does the damage. It is not tyres and it is not insurance. It is depreciation, at nearly ten cents a mile, and it is there for a boring reason: the EV cost $42,000 and the compact cost $24,000. A more expensive vehicle loses more value per year, and at 20,000 miles a year that lands squarely on the per-mile rate.
- Energy is the visible line and the misleading one. It moves weekly, the driver watches it, and it is the only large line where the EV is clearly ahead. Judging the whole comparison on it is how both the operator and I got this wrong in opposite directions.
- Maintenance is a real EV advantage and a modest one. No oil changes, fewer brake jobs because regenerative braking does most of the stopping. Worth about three and a half cents, not the transformation it gets described as.
- Tyres go the other way, and operators spot this first. More kerb weight on the same contact patch, plus instant torque from a standstill. EV tyres wear meaningfully faster, on the order of fifty percent, and that belongs in the rate.
When paying an EV driver less is the correct answer
Change one thing in the pairing above. Instead of a new EV against a new gas car, put a used EV against a used gas compact. Now the EV comes out about two and a half cents a mile cheaper, and the accurate rate for that driver is genuinely lower.
The reason is the depreciation line again. Used EV prices have fallen hard, so the capital gap that made the new EV expensive to own largely closes, while the energy gap does not close at all. Two cheap-to-charge vehicles, one of which no longer costs much more to own.
So the honest answer to the original objection is not "no, EVs always get paid the same". It is that the comparison depends on the two specific vehicles, and the only thing that is always wrong is deciding it from the fuel line.
What to do with this on Monday
- Do not set an EV rate by discounting your gas rate. That builds the fuel line into the answer and nothing else. Price the EV's six lines and compare the totals.
- Expect the EV rate to be higher on new vehicles and lower on used ones. If your program produces the same answer for both, it is not reading the depreciation line.
- Be able to show the driver the six lines. This is a conversation that goes badly on assertion and fine on arithmetic. A driver who can see that their energy saving was handed back in depreciation does not feel cheated.
- Write down what the rate assumed. Vehicle price, annual mileage, local energy price. A rate with its inputs stated can be checked and corrected. One without them can only be argued about.
The compliance angle, briefly
Paying different rates to different drivers sounds like the risky option and is actually the defensible one. Under the federal anti-kickback rule at 29 CFR 531.35, and in California under Labor Code section 2802, the exposure comes from reimbursing below actual cost. Parker v. Battle Creek Pizza, decided by the Sixth Circuit in 2024, rejected both the IRS rate as a required minimum and a reasonable approximation as a defence, leaving an evidence standard that rewards documentation. It binds Michigan, Ohio, Kentucky and Tennessee and is persuasive authority everywhere else. A single flat rate across a mixed fleet guarantees that somebody is under it.
Differentiating by vehicle is not favouritism. It is the only way a per-mile rate can be right for more than one driver at a time.
Where RatesReady fits
RatesReady prices every one of those six lines for each store location and each vehicle class, including EVs, with insurance built from carrier rate filings and energy from local fuel and electricity prices. The rate is documented line by line, so you can hand a driver the build rather than a number. It is $49 per location per month. You can request a demo, see the full cost build-up in our breakdown of a delivery mile, read why depreciation is the line most often missed, or check your current program against our reimbursement compliance audit.
Figures in this article and in the calculator above are modeled illustrations, not quotes. Insurance, depreciation and energy costs vary by ZIP code, vehicle and market. This is general information for operators and is not legal or tax advice; consult your own counsel on your obligations under federal and state wage law.